McCutchen, a five-time All-Star and 2013 NL MVP, is currently unsigned after hitting .239 with 13 homers last season. He also passed Roberto Clemente on Pittsburgh’s all-time home run list. However, sentiment doesn’t guarantee roster spots. As of February 2026, retirement isn’t official, but it’s clearly on the table.

Pittsburgh Pirates legend Andrew McCutchen called out the franchise on social media after being snubbed from their fan fest despite 12 seasons with the team.

Andrew McCutchen’s future with the Pirates has been up in the air all offseason, and the franchise icon has become more vocal about it on social media as Spring Training nears. The most direct message came late Saturday night,

The Pittsburgh Pirates are still open to re-signing Andrew McCutchen, but their relationship with the franchise legend isn't in a good place, according to The Athletic's Ken Rosenthal.

The Cleveland Guardians are being linked with a former MVP winner and five-time All-Star to give their lineup a boost.

The fan-favorite's fairytale return faced an inevitable, business-driven conclusion, overshadowing his storied Pirates legacy.

The Pittsburgh Pirates made a big move to start the week, adding veteran DH Marcell Ozuna on a one-year deal. Andrew McCutchen responded with a move of his own. The longtime Pirate removed references to the team from his social media profiles (hat tip to Josh Rowntree of 93.